Latah County to Ada County, IdahoLife sentences. Post conviction pending

State of Idaho v. Bryan Kohberger. A plea, and a second fight.

Four University of Idaho students were killed in an off campus home in Moscow on November 13, 2022. Bryan Kohberger was arrested six weeks later in Pennsylvania. After a venue change to Boise, he pleaded guilty in July 2025 to avoid the death penalty and is serving four consecutive life sentences. In 2026 he asked to withdraw that plea.

Hosted by RJ Manuelian, American criminal defense attorney, over 75 jury trials to verdictand Tony Petrossian, USC Law, filmmaker
46.73° N 117.00° W Case file No. 05Latah County to Ada County, IdahoMoscow, IDTrial venue moved to Boise Legal postureHomicidesNov 2022ArrestDec 2022Venue changeSep 2024PleaJul 2025Post convictionPending
  • PleaGuilty, Jul 2, 2025
  • SentenceFour consecutive life terms
  • JudgeSteven Hippler
  • NowPost conviction petition
State of Idaho v. Bryan C. Kohberger

The Backstory

In the early morning of November 13, 2022, four University of Idaho students were stabbed to death in a rented home near campus in Moscow, Idaho: Madison Mogen and Kaylee Goncalves, both 21, and Xana Kernodle and Ethan Chapin, both 20. The killings went unsolved for weeks.

On December 30, 2022, Bryan Kohberger, a criminology Ph.D. student at nearby Washington State University, was arrested at his parents’ home in eastern Pennsylvania. A Latah County grand jury indicted him in May 2023 on four counts of first degree murder and one count of burglary, and prosecutors gave notice they would seek the death penalty.

Citing saturation coverage in a small community, the defense won a change of venue. In September 2024 the case moved from Latah County to Ada County, where Judge Steven Hippler took over. On July 2, 2025, weeks before trial, Kohberger pleaded guilty to all five counts in exchange for the State dropping the death penalty. On July 23, 2025 he was sentenced to four consecutive terms of life without parole, plus ten years.

Because the plea waived a direct appeal, Kohberger’s remaining path is post conviction relief. In July 2026 he filed a petition claiming his plea was coerced and not knowing or voluntary, and in August 2026 his new lawyers moved to disqualify Judge Hippler. In October 2026 the judge vacated the disqualification hearing and the June 2027 evidentiary dates, ordering new dates to be set by August 2, 2027.

Court: Fourth Judicial District, Ada County, Idaho (from Latah County). Case reference: CR29-22-2805. Status verified Nov 19, 2026.

Analysis

The Defense Attorney’s Lens

The questions a trial lawyer with more than 75 jury trials to verdict asks first: what the State must prove, where the evidence will be fought over, and what can still go wrong.

i.

The elements

First degree murder in Idaho includes willful, deliberate, and premeditated killing. Once a defendant pleads guilty, those elements are no longer contested. The only question left is whether the plea itself was knowing, intelligent, and voluntary.

ii.

The evidentiary battleground

Before the plea, the battle was over touch DNA on a knife sheath, investigative genetic genealogy, cell phone location records, and a white sedan on surveillance video. The defense attacked how the genealogy lead was developed. A guilty plea took all of that off the table.

iii.

Why plea withdrawals rarely work

Courts give heavy weight to the plea colloquy, where the defendant swears under oath that no one threatened or promised him anything. To win, Kohberger must show his lawyers were constitutionally ineffective and that he would have gone to trial otherwise. If he succeeds, the death penalty could return.

iv.

The courtroom risk

A post conviction case reopens the attorney client file. Former defense counsel may be forced to testify about their advice, and everything said in the plea hearings becomes evidence against the petitioner.

Chronology

Case Timeline

  1. Four University of Idaho students are killed in Moscow, Idaho.

  2. Kohberger is arrested at his parents’ home in Pennsylvania.

  3. A Latah County grand jury indicts Kohberger on four murder counts and burglary.

  4. The court grants a change of venue. The case moves to Ada County and Judge Steven Hippler.

  5. Kohberger pleads guilty to all counts. The death penalty is withdrawn.

  6. Sentenced to four consecutive life terms without parole, plus ten years.

  7. Kohberger files a post conviction petition seeking to withdraw his plea.

  8. New counsel moves to disqualify Judge Hippler.

  9. The disqualification hearing and 2027 evidentiary dates are vacated, with new dates due by Aug 2, 2027.

Primary sources

Charges, Statutes & Sources

Every link on this page was opened and checked on Nov 19, 2026. Statutes are linked to official legislature portals or the Legal Information Institute at Cornell Law School. Everyone accused of a crime is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.

On the show

Hear the breakdown

Continue exploring

More Case Files

Every Case File follows the law from the first charge to the final ruling.

36.17° N 115.14° W Case file No. 01KEFFE DClark County, NevadaConvicted. Appeal pending
Clark County, Nevada

Duane “Keffe D” Davis and the Murder of Tupac Shakur

Convicted. Appeal pendingOpen the Case File
34.05° N 118.24° W Case file No. 02LIL DURKCentral District of CaliforniaAcquitted. Second trial set
Central District of California

United States v. Durk Banks (Lil Durk)

Acquitted. Second trial setOpen the Case File
42.04° N 70.67° W Case file No. 03LINDSAY CLANCYPlymouth County, MassachusettsMistrial. SJC review, retrial set
Plymouth County, Massachusetts

Commonwealth v. Lindsay Clancy

Mistrial. SJC review, retrial setOpen the Case File
42.16° N 71.14° W Case file No. 04KAREN READNorfolk County, MassachusettsAcquitted of murder. OUI conviction
Norfolk County, Massachusetts

Commonwealth v. Karen Read

Acquitted of murder. OUI convictionOpen the Case File
Requests & Voices

Which case should we open next?

Suggest the next Case File. RJ Manuelian reviews every request personally.