Norfolk County, MassachusettsAcquitted of murder. OUI conviction

Commonwealth v. Karen Read. Two trials. One verdict.

Boston police officer John O’Keefe was found in the snow outside a Canton home on January 29, 2022. Prosecutors said his girlfriend, Karen Read, struck him with her SUV. Her defense said she was framed. After a 2024 mistrial and a 2025 retrial, a jury acquitted Read of murder and manslaughter and convicted her only of drunk driving.

Hosted by RJ Manuelian, American criminal defense attorney, over 75 jury trials to verdictand Tony Petrossian, USC Law, filmmaker
42.16° N 71.14° W Case file No. 04Norfolk County, MassachusettsCanton, MANorfolk Superior Court, Dedham Legal postureDeathJan 2022IndictedJun 2022MistrialJul 2024VerdictJun 2025Civil suitsPending
  • VerdictNot guilty of murder
  • ConvictionOUI, one year probation
  • Retrial verdictJun 18, 2025
  • NowCivil cases pending
Commonwealth v. Karen Read

The Backstory

On the night of January 28, 2022, Karen Read and her boyfriend, Boston police officer John O’Keefe, went out drinking with friends in Canton, Massachusetts. Shortly after midnight on January 29, Read drove O’Keefe to an after party at the home of a fellow officer. Early that morning, during a snowstorm, Read and two others found O’Keefe’s body in the front yard. He had skull fractures, and hypothermia contributed to his death.

Read was arrested on February 1, 2022, and on June 9, 2022 a Norfolk County grand jury indicted her for second degree murder, manslaughter while operating under the influence, and leaving the scene of a collision causing death. Prosecutors said she backed her SUV into O’Keefe and drove away. The defense said O’Keefe was hurt inside the house and that investigators built a case against the wrong person.

The first trial ended in a mistrial on July 1, 2024 after the jury reported it could not agree. Read argued that jurors had privately agreed to acquit on two counts and that retrying her violated double jeopardy. On February 11, 2025, the Supreme Judicial Court rejected that argument because no verdict had been announced in open court.

The retrial began with jury selection on April 1, 2025. On June 18, 2025, after about 22 hours of deliberation, the jury found Read not guilty of second degree murder, manslaughter, and leaving the scene, and guilty of operating under the influence. She was sentenced to one year of probation. The O’Keefe family’s wrongful death suit and Read’s own civil rights suits remain open.

Court: Norfolk County Superior Court, Dedham, Massachusetts. Case reference: Norfolk County indictments, Jun 9, 2022. Status verified Nov 19, 2026.

Analysis

The Defense Attorney’s Lens

The questions a trial lawyer with more than 75 jury trials to verdict asks first: what the State must prove, where the evidence will be fought over, and what can still go wrong.

i.

The elements

Second degree murder requires malice. Manslaughter while OUI requires proof that impaired operation caused the death. Both depend on a single contested fact: did Read’s SUV strike O’Keefe at all? Without that, the case collapses to whether she was impaired behind the wheel.

ii.

The evidentiary battleground

Taillight fragments, the injuries on O’Keefe’s arm, vehicle data, phone timestamps, and the conduct of the investigation became the trial. The defense put the investigation itself on trial, and the lead investigator’s own messages about Read became evidence the jury could weigh against the Commonwealth.

iii.

The double jeopardy lesson

Read v. Commonwealth confirms that in Massachusetts a verdict exists only when it is announced in open court. A jury’s private agreement on some counts does not protect the defendant unless the judge takes a partial verdict. Defense lawyers now ask for that inquiry before any mistrial is declared.

iv.

The courtroom risk

A retrial gives both sides a transcript of the other’s case. Here it favored the defense, which sharpened its cross examination and narrowed the Commonwealth’s path to the single charge the jury believed.

Chronology

Case Timeline

  1. John O’Keefe is found outside a Canton home during a snowstorm.

  2. Read is arrested on a manslaughter charge.

  3. A Norfolk County grand jury indicts Read for second degree murder and related charges.

  4. The first trial ends in a mistrial after the jury reports a deadlock.

  5. The SJC rejects Read’s double jeopardy challenge.

  6. Retrial jury selection begins in Dedham.

  7. Not guilty of murder, manslaughter, and leaving the scene. Guilty of OUI. One year of probation.

  8. Read files a civil rights suit later removed to federal court.

Primary sources

Charges, Statutes & Sources

Every link on this page was opened and checked on Nov 19, 2026. Statutes are linked to official legislature portals or the Legal Information Institute at Cornell Law School. Everyone accused of a crime is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.

On the show

Hear the breakdown

Continue exploring

More Case Files

Every Case File follows the law from the first charge to the final ruling.

36.17° N 115.14° W Case file No. 01KEFFE DClark County, NevadaConvicted. Appeal pending
Clark County, Nevada

Duane “Keffe D” Davis and the Murder of Tupac Shakur

Convicted. Appeal pendingOpen the Case File
34.05° N 118.24° W Case file No. 02LIL DURKCentral District of CaliforniaAcquitted. Second trial set
Central District of California

United States v. Durk Banks (Lil Durk)

Acquitted. Second trial setOpen the Case File
42.04° N 70.67° W Case file No. 03LINDSAY CLANCYPlymouth County, MassachusettsMistrial. SJC review, retrial set
Plymouth County, Massachusetts

Commonwealth v. Lindsay Clancy

Mistrial. SJC review, retrial setOpen the Case File
46.73° N 117.00° W Case file No. 05BRYAN KOHBERGERLatah County to Ada County, IdahoLife sentences. Post conviction pending
Latah County to Ada County, Idaho

State of Idaho v. Bryan Kohberger

Life sentences. Post conviction pendingOpen the Case File
Requests & Voices

Which case should we open next?

Suggest the next Case File. RJ Manuelian reviews every request personally.