Plymouth County, MassachusettsMistrial. SJC review, retrial set

Commonwealth v. Lindsay Clancy. Eleven to one.

Three young children died in their Duxbury home on January 24, 2023. Their mother, Lindsay Clancy, did not dispute causing the deaths. Her defense argued postpartum psychosis left her without criminal responsibility. After seven days of deliberation, a jury deadlocked 11 to 1 and the judge declared a mistrial. The state’s highest court will now decide whether she can be tried again.

Hosted by RJ Manuelian, American criminal defense attorney, over 75 jury trials to verdictand Tony Petrossian, USC Law, filmmaker
42.04° N 70.67° W Case file No. 03Plymouth County, MassachusettsDuxbury, MAPlymouth Superior Court, Brockton Legal postureDeathsJan 2023IndictedSep 2023TrialJul 2026MistrialSep 2026SJC reviewJan 2027
  • First trialMistrial, Sep 4, 2026
  • JudgeWilliam F. Sullivan
  • SJC argumentsJanuary 2027
  • RetrialSet for Mar 29, 2027
Commonwealth v. Lindsay Clancy

The Backstory

On January 24, 2023, police in Duxbury, Massachusetts responded to a report that a woman had fallen from a window of a home on Summer Street. Inside, first responders found three children in the basement. Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, were pronounced dead. Their mother, Lindsay Clancy, a labor and delivery nurse, survived her fall with serious injuries.

Clancy was arraigned from a hospital bed on February 7, 2023, and a Plymouth County grand jury returned indictments on September 15, 2023 charging three counts of murder and three counts of strangulation or suffocation. Her defense did not dispute that she caused the deaths. It argued that postpartum psychosis left her lacking criminal responsibility under the Massachusetts standard first set out in Commonwealth v. McHoul.

The trial opened on July 27, 2026 before Judge William F. Sullivan and turned on competing expert testimony. Deliberations began on August 27. Notes from the foreperson reported an 11 to 1 deadlock, with eleven jurors favoring a finding of not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility, and one note said the holdout had acknowledged doubt but refused to apply it. On September 4, 2026, Judge Sullivan declared a mistrial without questioning or replacing that juror.

The defense moved to dismiss on double jeopardy grounds, arguing there was no manifest necessity for a mistrial. Judge Sullivan denied the motion and on November 16, 2026 set a retrial for March 29, 2027. On November 19, 2026, Supreme Judicial Court Justice Elizabeth N. Dewar sent Clancy’s petition to the full court on an expedited schedule, with arguments expected in January 2027.

Court: Plymouth County Superior Court, Massachusetts. Case reference: Plymouth County indictments, Sep 15, 2023. Status verified Nov 19, 2026.

Analysis

The Defense Attorney’s Lens

The questions a trial lawyer with more than 75 jury trials to verdict asks first: what the State must prove, where the evidence will be fought over, and what can still go wrong.

i.

The elements

Once the defense raises lack of criminal responsibility, Massachusetts places the burden on the Commonwealth to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant was criminally responsible. The fight is not over what happened. It is over the defendant’s mind at the moment it happened.

ii.

The evidentiary battleground

Psychiatric experts carried this trial. The defense presented postpartum psychosis as a medical emergency. The Commonwealth argued Clancy understood what she was doing and retained the capacity to choose otherwise. Jurors had to choose between experts on a question no one can directly observe.

iii.

The double jeopardy question

A mistrial is allowed only on manifest necessity. The defense argues the judge should have questioned a juror who, according to the foreperson’s note, refused to apply the reasonable doubt instruction, and could have seated an alternate. If the SJC agrees, the Commonwealth may be barred from trying her again.

iv.

The courtroom risk

Retrying a case where eleven jurors leaned toward a lack of responsibility finding is a strategic gamble for both sides. The Commonwealth now knows the defense experts’ playbook, and the defense now knows exactly where the holdout’s doubts landed.

Chronology

Case Timeline

  1. Cora, Dawson, and Callan Clancy are found in the family’s Duxbury home and die.

  2. Clancy is arraigned remotely from a hospital bed and pleads not guilty.

  3. A Plymouth County grand jury returns indictments.

  4. Opening statements in Plymouth Superior Court.

  5. Closing arguments. Deliberations begin.

  6. After seven days of deliberation and an 11 to 1 deadlock, Judge Sullivan declares a mistrial.

  7. Judge Sullivan denies the defense motion to dismiss on double jeopardy grounds.

  8. Retrial set for March 29, 2027, with a final pretrial hearing on March 18.

  9. SJC Justice Elizabeth N. Dewar sends the double jeopardy petition to the full court.

Primary sources

Charges, Statutes & Sources

Every link on this page was opened and checked on Nov 19, 2026. Statutes are linked to official legislature portals or the Legal Information Institute at Cornell Law School. Everyone accused of a crime is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.

On the show

Hear the breakdown

Continue exploring

More Case Files

Every Case File follows the law from the first charge to the final ruling.

36.17° N 115.14° W Case file No. 01KEFFE DClark County, NevadaConvicted. Appeal pending
Clark County, Nevada

Duane “Keffe D” Davis and the Murder of Tupac Shakur

Convicted. Appeal pendingOpen the Case File
34.05° N 118.24° W Case file No. 02LIL DURKCentral District of CaliforniaAcquitted. Second trial set
Central District of California

United States v. Durk Banks (Lil Durk)

Acquitted. Second trial setOpen the Case File
42.16° N 71.14° W Case file No. 04KAREN READNorfolk County, MassachusettsAcquitted of murder. OUI conviction
Norfolk County, Massachusetts

Commonwealth v. Karen Read

Acquitted of murder. OUI convictionOpen the Case File
46.73° N 117.00° W Case file No. 05BRYAN KOHBERGERLatah County to Ada County, IdahoLife sentences. Post conviction pending
Latah County to Ada County, Idaho

State of Idaho v. Bryan Kohberger

Life sentences. Post conviction pendingOpen the Case File
Requests & Voices

Which case should we open next?

Suggest the next Case File. RJ Manuelian reviews every request personally.